397 names.
Six ever got off.

And none of the six got out. Four moved to another taxation regime, one came back, and the last had never switched the Act on.

First Nations Fiscal Management ActS.C. 2005, c. 9 Schedule — ss. 2(1) and (3)Current to 21 September 2026

The Schedule

A council joins this list by passing one resolution. What it gets is a municipality’s fiscal powers without a municipality’s floor under them.

Why this exists

Russ Diabo — a Mohawk of Kahnawà:ke, publisher of the First Nations Strategic Bulletin, forty years on federal Indigenous policy and advisor to two national chiefs — posted that these institutions exist “to transition Indian Bands into municipal self-gov’t fiscal policy of loans & taxation,” and told people to check whether their community is on the list. Those are the Act’s own instruments — property tax, development cost charges, service fees, borrowing through a pooled authority against that revenue.

What is harder to see is what the model costs here. A British Columbia municipality in trouble is backstopped by a province-wide tax and cannot have its council replaced. A First Nation in trouble is backstopped by the other First Nations, and sections 52 and 53 let a federal board take “the exclusive authority to act in the place of the council” on an opinion that cannot be appealed. Same instrument, no floor under it.

All of that is public and none of it is in one place — it is spread across a hundred-page statute, 68 versions of a schedule, 67 orders in the Canada Gazette, three institutions’ annual reports and Canada’s audited financial statements. So the vote gets taken without the terms in view. This page assembles them.

Look up your community What to ask before signing

392 First Nations are named in the Schedule today. 397 have ever been named in it. 6 have been struck off, every one of them debt-free — and not one of the six left the arrangement. Four moved to another taxation regime, one came back, and the sixth had never switched the Act on.

That obligation, across every nation and twenty-one years, comes to $2.597 billion. On the same date Canada’s own audited statements provision $51.461 billion against Indigenous claims and litigation. The small debt has a clause that will not let you leave until it is paid. The large one has a queue 829 claims long.

§ 1

Look up a community

The list itself

All 397 names that have ever appeared, in the Schedule’s own alphabetical order. Struck names are kept in place and ruled through, the way a marked-up consolidation shows a repeal. Select a name for the date it was added, the order that added it, any earlier name it was listed under, and what the First Nations Financial Management Board has certified.

Four registers,
two of them readable

The instruction that prompted this page was to check the law “and the institutions set up by this law.” That is four registers, and only two can be read nation by nation from here. The other two are public in the sense that a person may look them up one at a time, and not in the sense that they can be assembled.

Have itThe Schedule. Complete, below, in every version published since 2005.
Have itThe Financial Management Board. From its published client roll — financial administration law, financial performance, financial management system. Shown against each name.
CannotThe Tax Commission’s register of enacted tax laws. Published in the First Nations Gazette, whose index renders only in a browser and refuses automated reading. 162 nations levy a tax under this Act; which 162 is not assemblable from here.
CannotThe Finance Authority’s borrowing members. Not published as a list at all. The count, 94, is in its annual report. The names are not anywhere.

So a blank in a row below means the Board has not certified that nation. It does not mean the nation is not taxing, and it does not mean it has not borrowed. Two of the four answers Russ Diabo told people to go and get are not, as published, gettable at scale.

Two names are given here as the communities spell them rather than as the statute does. The consolidated Schedule prints “?Aq’am” and “?Akisq’nuk First Nation” with a question mark where the glottal stop belongs. That is not a limit of the character set — three entries further down the same list, Yaq̓it ʔa·knuqⱡi’it carries the glottal stop correctly. Both misprinted names are Ktunaxa.

397 of 397 names 392 on the Schedule now 6 ever struck 1 came back

§ 2

It started empty

Royal assent 2005
Nobody listed until 2008

The Act received royal assent on 23 March 2005 and came into force on 1 April 2006 with nothing in the Schedule at all. The first 33 names were added by SOR/2007-276, registered 6 December 2007 and in force on 1 January 2008 — two years and nine months after the Act itself.

Since then the Minister has amended the Schedule 67 times by order, and Parliament once by statute. Nobody has ever been put on it by the Crown’s initiative: subsection 2(3) only lets the Minister act at the request of the council of a band, and every order in the Gazette recites that request.

010020030040020062010201420182022202612345
01002003004002006201120162021202612345
Names in the Schedule at each of the 68 dates it has changed. Red rings mark the 6 deletions; the dashed rules numbered 1 to 5 mark the 5 times Parliament enlarged the Act itself. Source: the consolidated Schedule published at laws-lois.justice.gc.ca, every point-in-time version.

It does not arrive
one at a time

397 names reached the Schedule in 60 orders. Only 2 of those orders carried a single name. The largest carried 33, and 193 names — 49% of everyone who has ever been listed — arrived in batches of ten or more. Whatever else this is, it is not 397 councils arriving at the same conclusion independently.

And the Act grows too

Parliament has enlarged the Act 5 times, counting every amending statute that touched four or more of its provisions. Each enlargement is bigger than the last, and until 2023 every one of them rode inside a budget or omnibus bill rather than arriving as a bill of its own.

Parliament enlarged the Act Prov. 12 mo
before
12 mo
after
1 Jobs and Economic Growth Act
2010, c. 12 · assent 12 July 2010
438
2 Jobs, Growth and Long-term Prosperity Act
2012, c. 19 · assent 29 June 2012
342515
3 Economic Action Plan 2015 Act, No. 1
2015, c. 36 · assent 23 June 2015
303419
4 Budget Implementation Act, 2018, No. 2
2018, c. 27 · assent 13 December 2018
634618
5 An Act to amend the First Nations Fiscal Management Act
2023, c. 16 · assent 20 June 2023
902316

Provisions counted from the historical notes in the Act’s consolidated XML. Addition counts exclude the 33 founding names, which populated the Schedule rather than joining it; the baseline rate over the period since is 20.6 names a year.

The direction is the one worth noticing, because it is the opposite of the obvious reading. The list does not fill up after Parliament widens the Act. It fills up before. In the twelve months preceding an enlargement the Schedule took on 26.2 names a year on average; in the twelve months after, 15.2. The baseline is 20.6.

So the constituency is assembled first and the statute is widened to fit it. This page does not claim to know why, and 5 enlargements is a small number — it is a pattern, not a proof, and one more amendment could overturn it.

§ 3

The six that left

Par. 2(3)(b)

A council may ask to come off the list. The Minister may agree — as long as there are no amounts owing by the band to the First Nations Finance Authority that remain unpaid. That is the entire condition, and it is the only one.

In twenty-one years it has been satisfied 6 times. Each order in the Gazette carries the same recital before the operative words: “And whereas, pursuant to paragraph 2(3)(b) of that Act, the band has no amounts owing to the First Nations Finance Authority.” Two of the six left on entering a treaty. Two moved their taxation to section 83 of the Indian Act. One opted out. One came back.

Where they went

The six are usually read as six escapes. They are not. Set the destination beside each one and the column empties out.

Struck offAnd then
Tsawwassen, 2010Property taxation under its treaty
Alexander, 2011Property taxation under s. 83 of the Indian Act
Chippewas of Kettle and Stony Point, 2012Back on the Schedule, 2014
Okanagan, 2019Property taxation under s. 83 of the Indian Act
Mohawks of Akwesasne, 2019Had never enacted a law or borrowed
Whitecap Dakota, 2023Real property taxation under its treaty, with a tax agreement with Canada
Nobody got out Four of the six moved to another taxation regime, one returned, and the sixth had never switched the Act on. Not one First Nation that actually used this apparatus has ever left it. And two of the four moved to section 83 of the Indian Act, which the same Commission oversees — its own count is 180 taxing First Nations, 162 under this Act and 18 under the Indian Act. Alexander and Okanagan moved from one column of that table to the other.

Which way the list
has been moving

Those 6 exits are the part that gets counted. The register also records the direction of travel, and it only goes one way. The last name to come off was Whitecap Dakota First Nation, on 1 September 2023. Since that day 39 First Nations have been added and none removed.

YearAdded Removed
2022+25—
2023+19−1
2024+12—
2025+13—
2026+7—

Counted from the 68 consolidations and the orders behind them. Lifetime: 397 added, 6 removed.

Par. 2(3)(b) has not changed. The Act was last amended on 24 April 2026 and the power to delete a name survived it untouched. The door is open, unchanged, and has not been used in three years.

So is being off the list
being outside it?

No, and that is the thing the Schedule’s shape hides. The list is one door into a building with several. A First Nation can tax under this Act, under section 83 of the Indian Act, or under a modern treaty, and the first two are supervised by the same Commission. 18 nations are taxing today having never been on the Schedule at all.

Leaving changes which instrument applies. On the record so far it has not, for anyone, meant leaving the arrangement.

§ 4

Two ledgers

What the list is for

Addition to the Schedule is the door, not the room. It makes a First Nation eligible for the four institutions the Act creates — the Tax Commission, the Financial Management Board, the Finance Authority and, since 2023, the Infrastructure Institute. Each step after that is a separate decision with its own gate, and the numbers thin out fast.

What has been lent, against the gap the lender itself publishes

$2.597B
Lent to First Nations in twenty-one years — the entire Finance Authority loan book
$349.2B
The First Nations infrastructure gap, named by the Authority in the same annual report
0.74%
The first as a share of the second
$51.461B
And what Canada provisions against Indigenous claims in its own audited statements — 20 times the loan book

The money Canada says it owes is 20 times the money it has lent.

$349.2B − $2.597B = $346.6B of the gap unfinanced. Source for both the loan book and the gap: First Nations Finance Authority, Annual Report 2024–2025.

What is inside
the gap

A gap of $349.2B is an abstraction until you ask what is in it. Two things in it are measured and published by the Crown every year.

Water. 38 long-term drinking water advisories were in effect in 36 communities as at 10 September 2026. 158 have been lifted since November 2015, which is the figure usually quoted; the 38 that remain are the ones that have outlasted two governments and a stated commitment to end them.

Fire. In 2022 the Auditor General examined emergency management in First Nations communities and found that Indigenous Services Canada “spent 3.5 times more on responding to emergencies than on supporting First Nations communities to prepare for them” — about $828 million over four years. As of April 2022, 39% of structural mitigation projects were eligible and waiting for funding. The same report notes that for every dollar invested in preparedness, $6 can be saved in response and recovery.

And this was not news to the department. The Auditor General’s words: “Many issues have not improved since we first identified them in our 2013 audit of emergency management on reserves.” Nine years, the same finding, twice.

Which is the shape in § 7 arriving early. Canada mandates cost-benefit analysis before it makes a rule, and its own auditor has already done the arithmetic here — one to 6 — and the allocation went 3.5 to one the other way.

Indigenous Services Canada, Ending long-term drinking water advisories, page modified 11 September 2026 · Office of the Auditor General of Canada, Report 8 — Emergency Management in First Nations Communities, 2022.

The debt that runs one way

Local revenues raised under the Act reached a record $140 million in 2025–26, up from $95 million five years earlier. The Finance Authority is rated AA−, has 185 members, and its loan book stands at $2.597 billion. That is the whole obligation this Act has created, in twenty-one years, across every First Nation on the list.

And the one that runs the other

Crown–Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada publishes audited financial statements. At 31 March 2025 the department carried total liabilities of $61.562 billion, of which $51.461 billion — 83.6% — is a provision for claims and litigation.

Both ledgers, 31 March 2025

$2.597B Owed by First Nations — the entire Finance Authority loan book, every nation, twenty-one years
$51.461B Provisioned by Canada against Indigenous claims and litigation, in its own audited statements

Canada’s own accountants put what it probably owes at 20 times everything First Nations have borrowed under this Act.

Also on that date: $666.0M held by the Crown as Indian moneys · $10B paid in 2023 to settle one treaty annuity frozen since 1874 · sources: Finance Authority Annual Report 2024–25 note 6, CIRNAC and Indigenous Services Canada financial statements.

What is behind the provision

829 specific claims under negotiation. 94 comprehensive land claims. 425 pending and threatened litigation claims. 25 special claims. In the department’s own definition, a specific claim concerns Canada’s obligations under historic treaties “or the way it managed First Nations’ funds or other assets.” The mismanagement of the money is itself one of the things being counted.

Canada’s own accountants put what it probably owes at roughly 20 times everything First Nations have borrowed through this Act.

Indian moneys
ss. 61–69, Indian Act

The funds themselves are smaller than people think. At 31 March 2025 the Crown held $666.0 million in Indian moneys in the Consolidated Revenue Fund — $586.6M in band funds, $22.9M in savings accounts, $56.5M in estates.

Two different claims get mixed together here and they need separating. There is no account holding trillions — the balance is what it is, and the Yellowhead Institute debunk the secret-account version at length. That is a statement about an account. It is not a statement about what was taken being worth trillions today, which is a different proposition and a live one.

The smallness is the finding, not the refutation. Yellowhead’s sum of the closing balances from the mid-1850s to now is over $36 billion — money that passed through the account and left, lent to the Crown to run itself and spent on canals and universities. Three provisions of the Indian Act are still in force:

61(2)Interest on Indian moneys held in the Consolidated Revenue Fund is allowed “at a rate to be fixed from time to time by the Governor in Council.” The debtor sets the rate it pays you.
64(1)Capital moneys may be spent only where, with the council’s consent, “the Minister may authorize and direct” it. Permission is required to spend your own money.
67“Where money is expended by Her Majesty for the purpose of raising or collecting Indian moneys, the Minister may authorize the recovery of the amount so expended from the moneys of the band.” The Crown may bill the band for the cost of collecting the band’s money.

What it is worth now
depends on the index

Here is why the size of the answer is contested, on one promise whose numbers are all public. The Robinson Huron annuity was fixed at $4 a person in 1874, when gold was $20.67 an ounce under the gold standard. Four dollars bought 0.1935 of an ounce. Gold closed at $4,180 an ounce on 2 October 2026.

$4 a person, promised 1874, carried to today

$4
What is actually still paid
$118
Carried on consumer prices — what it would buy
$809
Carried on gold — what it was, held
never
computed
What the treaty actually promised — a share of the wealth the land produced

The choice of index is not a technicality. It is the argument.

$4 ÷ $20.67/oz = 0.1935 oz × $4,180/oz = $809 · CPI factor 29.4× (US CPI, 1874–2026) · gold has moved 202× against 29.4× for consumer prices.

Consumer prices say the annuity should be $118. Gold says $809 — 6.9 times more. And neither is what the treaty said. It promised the payment would rise with the wealth the land produced, and over that territory that is mining and forestry revenue, which is larger again than either index. The choice of index is not a technicality. It is the argument.

Consumer prices treat the money as shopping forgone. Gold treats it as a holding. A trust is the second thing, not the first.

Ermineskin, 2009 SCC 9

Which is exactly what was litigated, and lost. Two Alberta nations argued that the Crown, holding their oil and gas royalties, was obliged to invest them as a prudent trustee would rather than parking them in the Consolidated Revenue Fund at an administratively set bond rate. A unanimous Supreme Court held that the Crown has a fiduciary relationship with respect to the money but no obligation or authority to invest it.

So the gap between what a trustee would have earned and what the Governor in Council decided to pay is not a rounding error and not a grievance. It is lawful, it compounds for as long as the money is held, and the Supreme Court has said the Crown may keep it.

§ 5

Only one of them is enforceable

Par. 2(3)(b)

The smaller debt has a statutory lock. A council may ask to come off the list, and the Minister may agree, as long as there are no amounts owing by the band to the First Nations Finance Authority that remain unpaid. Six nations have satisfied it in twenty-one years, and every order recites it.

Section 77

A borrowing member that has taken a loan may stop being one “only with the consent of all other borrowing members.” Not the lender’s consent. Every other borrowing First Nation in the country.

Subs. 84(2), (5)

The Authority withholds 5% of every loan into a debt reserve fund. If that fund is drawn down by half or more, it shall require every borrowing member with an unpaid loan to pay “without delay” whatever it takes to refill it. One nation’s default is a bill to all the others.

Subs. 5(1)
Local revenue laws

The law-making powers are municipal in form and the Act says so in detail: assessment of reserve lands, tax rates, taxation of business activities, development cost charges, fees for water, sewers, waste, animal control, recreation and transportation. Enforcement runs to liens on reserve lands, interest and penalties, seizure and sale of personal property, the seizure, forfeiture and assignment of interests or rights in reserve lands, and the discontinuance of services.

Sections 52, 53
53.1 added 2023

On the Board’s opinion that there is “a serious risk” of default — not on an actual default — it may impose co-management, or assume third-party management and take “the exclusive authority to act in the place of the council of the First Nation”: to make the nation’s laws, manage its revenues, deliver or terminate its programs and services, and assign interests in its reserve lands. Section 53.1, added in 2023, extends that from property tax to other revenues — business income, lease revenue, provincial and municipal transfers, royalties — and lets the Board manage them “including those that are comingled with other moneys of the First Nation.” The words “final and conclusive and is not subject to appeal” appear 7 times in the Act, attached to the opinions all of this rests on.

Never used None of it has ever been fired. The lender’s own 2024–25 annual report: “FNFA has never had a member default on a loan or had to enact any of the protections.” Its audited statements record no impairment provision to 31 March 2025, nor in 2024. Twenty-one years, $2.597 billion lent, 94 borrowers, not one default.

The other queue

The larger debt has no lock, no privative clause and no automatic trigger. It has a negotiation queue 829 claims long, and the alternative is court.

In 2023 Canada and Ontario settled the Robinson Huron annuities for $10 billion, $5 billion each, with 21 First Nations. The promise was that the annuity would rise with the wealth the land produced. It was frozen at $4 a person in 1874 and never moved again. In July 2024 the Supreme Court left the settlement standing and described Canada as a historically dishonourable treaty partner.

One hundred and seventy-four years from the promise to the payment.

§ 6

Municipal, without the municipality

Checking the claim
that started this

The post that prompted this page says the institutions exist “to transition Indian Bands into municipal self-gov’t fiscal policy of loans & taxation.” Read it exactly: the claim is about a fiscal policy model, not about status. On that, the record agrees with him, and it is not close.

Property taxation of land. Development cost charges. Fees for water, sewers, waste, animal control, recreation and transportation. Borrowing against that revenue through a pooled authority that issues debentures, holds a sinking fund and keeps a debt reserve. That is the municipal fiscal model, item for item, and the Finance Authority was built to copy one — British Columbia’s local governments borrow through the Municipal Finance Authority of BC, a pooled lender of the same design.

So the useful thing is not to argue with the description. It is to put the two side by side and see what the municipal model costs when it is applied to a First Nation.

Municipalities
MFA of BC
First Nations
the Finance Authority
Debt outstanding$5.747B $2.597B
CoveringOne province All of Canada
Credit ratingAAAAA−
Debt reserve withheld from each loan1% 5%
Who refills the reserve after a draw A province-wide tax The other borrowers
Can a board replace the council?No Yes, ss. 52–53
Losses to dateNone in 50+ years None in 21 years

S&P Global Ratings research update on MFABC, 2025, and MFABC’s 2025 annual report · Finance Authority Annual Report 2024–25 · Act, subss. 84(2) and (2.1).

The row that matters

Most of that table is unremarkable. A pooled lender, a debt reserve, a sinking fund, an exclusive relationship with its members — that is simply how municipal finance works in Canada, and the Finance Authority was built to the same pattern on purpose. The 5% withholding is higher than the municipal 1%, but the Act lets the board cut it to 1%, so even that is a dial rather than a difference.

One row is not like the others. S&P describes the municipal authority’s “legislatively enshrined ability to levy a province-wide tax to replenish any potential draw on its debt reserve fund.” When a BC municipality fails, the whole province pays. When a First Nation fails, subsection 84(5) says the other borrowing First Nations pay, “without delay.”

Same instrument. One has a sovereign underneath it and one does not, and the difference is visible in the rating: AAA against AA−. That gap is a price, charged on every dollar borrowed, for the absence of a backstop.

What it is,
and what it is not

A municipality receives these powers by statute, automatically, on incorporation. It does not apply. There is no schedule to be added to, no ministerial order, no federal board that must approve its internal financial law before it may borrow, and no body that can take “the exclusive authority to act in the place of” its council on an opinion that cannot be appealed.

A First Nation does all of that, backstops the pool itself, and borrows at a worse rate. So the characterisation holds, and the comparison makes it worse rather than better. The fiscal model really is the municipal one. What does not come with it is the thing that makes the municipal one survivable: a province standing behind the debt, and nobody empowered to replace the council.

Municipal in the obligations. Not municipal in the protections. The furniture without the floor, and a supervisor in the room.

And the scale answers the other half. The entire national apparatus — $2.597 billion, across every First Nation that has ever borrowed under this Act — is less than half what one province’s local governments owe through theirs.

§ 7

The calculation nobody has done

Three numbers Canada
already publishes

One. Treasury Board sets a Value of a Statistical Life — the figure a regulator uses to decide whether preventing a death is worth what it costs. The Policy on Cost-Benefit Analysis is not advisory about it: departments “must use the VSL specified in TBS’s Cost-Benefit Analysis Guide” and “must express the VSL in constant dollars of their desired price year using Statistics Canada’s Consumer Price Index.” The published value is $6.5 million in 2007 dollars, $9.1 million in 2020 dollars, and around $11 million once indexed to now.

Two. Statistics Canada publishes the life expectancy gap, by group, by sex.

Three. The census publishes the populations.

2021Years below
non-Indigenous
Population
First Nations8.9 m · 9.6 f 1,048,405
Inuit11.4 m · 11.2 f 70,540
Métis4.5 m · 5.0 f 624,220
Multiple or other Indigenous identities— 64,085
Total— 1,807,250

Treasury Board Secretariat, Policy on Cost-Benefit Analysis and the Cost-Benefit Analysis Guide · Statistics Canada life expectancy projections, 2021 · Census of Population, 2021.

What they are for

Those three are the inputs to a calculation the federal government performs routinely and is required to perform before it makes a rule. A department multiplies them to decide whether an intervention is worth its cost. The instrument does not ask why anyone died. The same figure is applied to a highway curve, to benzene in the air, and to a water system that was never funded.

27 October 2022

On that date the House of Commons gave unanimous consent to a motion recognising the residential school system as genocide, citing the 1948 Convention by name. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission had said “cultural genocide” in 2015; the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls said genocide in 2019. Parliament dropped the qualifier four years ago.

Three numbers, published every year

  •  A Value of a Statistical Life that every federal department must use before it makes a rule — $9.1 million.
  • ×An Indigenous life expectancy gap, measured to a tenth of a year.
  • ×A population of 1,807,250.

= and Canada has never carried it out.

Not in the Public Accounts. Not in CIRNAC’s $51.461 billion provision. Not in any departmental cost-benefit analysis this page could locate. An absence cannot be proved the way a figure can, so: if such a document exists it would be worth seeing, and it would change this section rather than the argument.

The multiplication, carried out here — Canada’s price, Canada’s gap, Canada’s census

13.46M
Years of life lost — the measured gap × the counted population
$475,886
What one of those years is worth, at the VSL indexed to now and the 3% rate Canada uses for health
$6.41T
The product
$2.19T
– $11.11T
The range across every published VSL vintage and every discount rate the guide allows

The cell is empty. That is not the same as small.

Years lost = population × the mean of the male and female gap: 9,697,746 First Nations · 2,965,045 Métis · 797,102 Inuit. The 64,085 who reported multiple or other Indigenous identities are left out, because no gap is published for them. A VSL prices a prevented death, so it is converted to a value per life-year across 40 years of remaining life — multiplying a VSL by a population would value every life in full, which is a different calculation and a wrong one.

Every cell,
not one of them

Three published VSL vintages against the three discount rates the guide works in. No cell here is an estimate of anything: each is Canada’s own figure applied to Canada’s own measurement, which is what the Policy on Cost-Benefit Analysis requires of a department before it makes a rule.

Value of a Statistical Life 0%3% 7%
$6.5M, 2007 dollars$2.19T$3.78T$6.56T
$9.1M, 2020 dollars$3.06T$5.30T$9.19T
$11M, indexed to now$3.70T$6.41T$11.11T

Discount rate applied to 40 years of remaining life expectancy. Canada uses 3% for health and safety; the guide also works in 0% and 7%. The spread is the choice of rate, not a disagreement about the gap.

The rate is the same kind of choice as the index in § 4, and it moves the answer by a factor of five. There is no neutral setting. What there is instead is a published price, a published gap, a published population, and no federal document that puts them in a line.

The second time
on this page

This is not a secret and it is not a cover-up. It is the same shape as the gap in § 4. The treaty promised the annuity would rise with the wealth the land produced, and that was never calculated either. Canada mandates a price for a prevented death, measures the shortfall to a tenth of a year, publishes both, and has never once carried out the multiplication.

A figure that is never computed cannot be owed, cannot be provisioned for, and cannot appear in a queue of 829 claims. Not computing it is the mechanism.

The reading

Nobody is put on this list. All 397 names got there because a council asked, and the Gazette proves it line by line. The powers that frightened me when I first read the Act have never once been used, and the lender advertises that as a feature, which for its purposes it is.

What is left when you take the alarm out is an asymmetry of enforcement. Two debts sit on the same balance date. The small one, $2.597 billion, is collected by operation of a statute: a clause in paragraph 2(3)(b) that will not let a nation off the list until it is paid. The large one, $51.461 billion, is collected by outliving the Crown’s lawyers.

Nor is the list the edge of anything. Of the six struck off, four moved to another taxation regime — two to section 83 of the Indian Act, which the same Commission supervises, and two to their own treaties. One came back. The sixth had never enacted a law under the Act in the first place. No First Nation that used this apparatus has ever left it, and 18 are taxing today having never been listed at all.

And there is a third ledger that has never been opened at all. Canada mandates a price for a prevented death, measures the Indigenous life expectancy gap to a tenth of a year, publishes both every year, and has never multiplied them. Parliament called the system genocide in 2022 and not one figure moved — not the provision, not the settlements, not a single departmental analysis.

So the question Russ Diabo put — check whether your community is on this list — has a sharper form. Not are you on it, which 392 nations chose. Which ledger has a lock on it, which has a queue, and which was never written down.

§ 8

What to ask before signing

Six questions
and one for Canada

Joining takes one band council resolution and the Tax Commission supplies a sample. These are the questions the resolution does not raise, each one answerable from the Act itself. They are not arguments against joining — 392 councils weighed it and said yes. They are the terms, in the order a council would want them.

  1. What can actually be taken if we default?

    Liens on reserve lands. Interest and penalties. Seizure and sale of personal property. The seizure, forfeiture and assignment of interests or rights in reserve lands. Discontinuance of services.

    Subs. 5(1)(e)

  2. Who decides we are in trouble, and can we appeal it?

    The Financial Management Board, on its own opinion that there is “a serious risk” of default — it does not have to wait for one. It may then take “the exclusive authority to act in the place of the council.” The words “final and conclusive and is not subject to appeal” appear 7 times in the Act.

    Sections 52, 53

  3. Does this reach money that is not property tax?

    Since 2023, yes. Business income, lease revenue, provincial and municipal transfers, royalties — and the Board may manage them “including those that are comingled with other moneys of the First Nation.”

    Section 53.1, added 2023

  4. What happens to us if a different First Nation defaults?

    The Authority holds back 5% of every loan into a shared reserve. If that reserve is drawn down by half, it shall require every borrowing member with an unpaid loan to refill it “without delay.” The exposure is joint.

    Subs. 84(2), (5)

  5. How do we get out?

    Ask the Minister, who may agree — as long as nothing is owed to the Finance Authority. And if you have borrowed, you may stop being a borrowing member “only with the consent of all other borrowing members”: every other borrowing First Nation in Canada.

    Par. 2(3)(b) · Section 77

  6. Has any of this ever actually happened?

    No. Twenty-one years, $2.597 billion lent, 94 borrowers, not one default and not one intervention. Ask this question last and weigh the first five against the answer. A power that has never been used is still a power, and section 53.1 is two years old.

    Finance Authority Annual Report 2024–25

  7. And one to put to Canada

    Treasury Board requires every department to price a prevented death before it makes a rule. Statistics Canada measures the Indigenous life expectancy gap to a tenth of a year. Why has no federal analysis ever multiplied them? It is a fair question for a Member of Parliament, and the answer is not on this page because it is not anywhere.

    § 7 above

§ 9

Pass it on

13 cards

Every card is its own page with its own preview image, so a posted link shows the card and not a generic logo. Post one, or take the picture and put it anywhere you like. The figures on them are the ones on this page, and each card links back to it.

13 cards · 1080×1080 · tap to open, download to post

What this does not show

Sources

  1. First Nations Fiscal Management Act, S.C. 2005, c. 9 — Schedule, and all 68 point-in-time versions of it published on the Justice Laws Website. Full text of the Act.
  2. Canada Gazette, Part II — the 67 orders and one statute that have amended the Schedule, including SOR/2007-276 (the first 33 names), SOR/2010-254, SOR/2011-27, SOR/2012-30, SOR/2019-31 and SOR/2019-324.
  3. First Nations Tax Commission, Annual Report 2025–2026 — 180 taxing First Nations, 162 of them under the Act, $140M in local revenues, 61% of all First Nations participating.
  4. First Nations Finance Authority, Annual Report 2024–2025 — loans to 94 borrowing members (2024: 81), $2.597B in debenture financing, 185 members, and the $349.2B infrastructure gap.
  5. First Nations Financial Management Board, client register — financial administration law approvals and financial performance and management system certifications.
  6. S&P Global Ratings, research update on the Municipal Finance Authority of British Columbia, 2025, and MFABC’s 2025 annual report — $5.747B outstanding, AAA, the 1% debt reserve and the province-wide tax that replenishes it.
  7. Crown–Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada, financial statements for the year ended 31 March 2025 — total liabilities $61.562B, provision for claims and litigation $51.461B (83.6%), and the counts of specific, comprehensive, special and litigation claims under negotiation.
  8. Indigenous Services Canada, financial statements for the year ended 31 March 2025 — Indian moneys held in the Consolidated Revenue Fund: band funds $586.6M, savings $22.9M, estates $56.5M.
  9. Indian Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. I-5, ss. 61–69 — the management of Indian moneys, the Governor-in-Council interest rate, ministerial authorisation of capital expenditure, and the recovery of collection costs from the band.
  10. Yellowhead Institute, Cash Back — the Indian Trust Fund — the historic sum of closing balances, and the correction to the trillion-dollar claim.
  11. Ontario (Attorney General) v. Restoule, 2024 SCC 27, and the 2023 Robinson Huron annuities settlement — $10B, $5B each from Canada and Ontario, 21 First Nations, on an annuity frozen at $4 a person in 1874.
  12. Treasury Board of Canada Secretariat, Policy on Cost-Benefit Analysis and the Cost-Benefit Analysis Guide — departments “must use the VSL specified” and must index it to CPI. $6.5M in 2007 dollars, $9.1M in 2020 dollars.
  13. Statistics Canada, life expectancy projections for First Nations, Métis and Inuit household populations, 2021, and the 2021 Census of Population — the gaps and the populations in § 7.
  14. House of Commons, 27 October 2022 — unanimous consent to the motion recognising the residential school system as genocide under the 1948 Convention.
  15. An Act to amend the Interpretation Act, S.C. 2024, c. 30 — the Act’s own non-derogation clause was repealed in 2024 and replaced by a general provision covering every federal enactment, not removed.